My Response to a Psychiatric Times Blog Entry by Psychiatrist Carol A. Paris M.D. Concerning the Tribulations of Working with Health Insurance Companies

It seems to me that this kind of criticism of the insurance industry misses the more important point. As a psychiatrist, I am not enamored of piles of paperwork, debating with peer reviewers, and feeling that my patients are sometimes denied important services on the basis of cost. But, many physician complaints about the system seem, to me, narrow in scope, if not downright self-serving.

I was practicing in California when managed care arrived in the mid 80′s. I hated those calls from insurance companies that made me feel that my competence and judgment were being questioned. Then again, some of my colleagues were keeping patients in the hospital until their insurance ran out, declaring them cured, and discharging them. And there’s the psychiatrist I knew who was billing for psychotherapy with a patient in an ICU who was in a coma. I accept the few bad apples theory, but physician greed certainly contributed to the backlash that occurred.

At the present time, over 16% of our population has no health insurance, yet we’re spending an almost identical proportion of our gross domestic product on health care, and bankrupting our system. All the complaining in the world won’t change the fact that something’s got to give. We can blame overpaid CEO’s, an excess of mid-level managers at the companies we revile, lawyers and politicians, but let’s look at ourselves. All too often, we think of our patients, our income, all the rewards we were promised for staying up all night studying or working 72 hour shifts as house officers, piling up debt while our friends were working for a decent wage and having fun.

We’re not entitled to anything. Nobody is. Let’s accept current realities or work to change them instead of holding pity parties for ourselves.

Link to original blog:

About these ads

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s